There has been some recent discussion on other blogs (
Brett and
Ochuck) regarding statement's of faith. This has apparently come out of some current debate in the Church about the need for such statements and, presumably, their effect on reaching the unchurched.
I'll be honest. I haven't read up much on this topic. It has struck a chord with me, though, because I went to a
church that seemed to have this "ideal" of no statement of faith (they do have a "Things of Importance" section on their website). This seemed quite enjoyable at first. Everything was very community oriented. I appreciated the people.
That was fine until the pastor declared, "the bible is not the word of God." He opened it up to questions later and I asked him about that statement. He told me that Jesus was the Word of God, not the bible, and our reason for believing the bible is that "it's our story."
First off, he was wrong about the bible (
here's an example of Jesus calling Scripture the word of God). I got curious about the other beliefs of the church, so I emailed him a list of questions. He responded by telling me that the church "has no official stance" on any of my questions. One of those questions was "how is one saved?" Through a series of emails, my questions were avoided and no answer was given. To be honest, the responses came across as arrogant to me. Eventually, he told me essentially that he agreed with me on salvation (the question it eventually boiled down to), but was hurt that I "accused" him of not believing that it came through faith in Christ. Since he hadn't told me he believed it did, I had no reason to believe that was his stance.
I use a specific example not to say that others are like this, but that it is vital to know what we believe as Christians, and to be able to have unifying statements based on Scripture (superfluous beliefs aside - statements of faith are
foundational, not based on
disputable matters). One cannot build without a
foundation to stand on. Without it, discussion even amongst believers becomes futile and painful.
My question becomes, then, to those who believe that there shouldn't be a statement of faith (or something similar): on what ground should a group of believers stand? The ground of Christ, yes, but we see today with the popularity of things such as the Gospel of Judas that standing on Christ means more than just an ambiguous declaration of belief. Christ has come to mean whatever anyone wants him to mean.
Scripture tells us:
...Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have... 1 Peter 3:15
And at another point it says
Watch your life and doctrine closely. Persevere in them, because if you do, you will save both yourself and your hearers. 1 Timothy 4:16
I think this speaks to a bigger issue of life, which is that people need definition. They need to know who they are, where they belong, and what the heck they're doing in life. Without that, people have no direction. This is not to say one should blindly follow some code they don't know about. But think of all those movies where you see the hero being trained for battle by his instructor. There are rules to follow - a code - a set of beliefs. They may not be written, but they sure are clear.
This principle can be plainly seen in the military. The Marine Corps still remains one of the least softened forces in the military. They don't have a huge problem with recruitment either. People join the Corps because they crave definition, rules, and the like. There is also, within this, a strong sense of community and belonging since everyone knows their purpose.
The same should go for the Church. Are we not part of God's Army? Sure, the Church is not be the military. It is a
relationship with God, I agree. But without a set of codes - a clear goal - a set of principles - a battle cry - a foundation to stand on - a community of a singular purpose... out of what are we to act? How are we to know even what we believe is true? On faith? Yes, but faith is pointless if it isn't clear.
I have been somewhat disenfranchised from church recently not because of too many statements of faith, but with the idea that doctrine has little value, that the bible's words can mean different things, and that Christianity is a religion of feelings. I just don't believe that that is the Bride that Christ desires.
P.S. As a disclaimer, none of this was in direct response to anything on any other blog or directed towards anyone in particular. Just merely a ranting of my own thoughts...